Nestar Russell's doctoral dissertation, titled Understanding Willing Participants, offers a comprehensive sociological analysis of Stanley Milgram's obedience experiments. This two-volume work delves into the organizational and bureaucratic structures that facilitated participants' compliance in administering what they believed were harmful electric shocks to others.
Key Themes and Contributions:
-
Bureaucratic Structure and Responsibility Diffusion: Russell examines how the hierarchical setup of Milgram's experiments, with defined roles from the experimenter to the participant, allowed individuals to diffuse personal responsibility. This structure made it psychologically easier for participants to comply with directives that led to harmful actions.
-
Non-Human Technologies and Emotional Disconnection: The use of the shock generator and physical barriers (like the wall separating the participant from the learner) served as "strain-resolving mechanisms." These tools created emotional and physical distance, reducing participants' immediate sense of the consequences of their actions and facilitating compliance.Academia+1Academia+1
-
Bureaucratic Momentum: Russell introduces the concept of "bureaucratic momentum," highlighting how the procedural aspects of the experiment—such as scheduled time slots and the systematic processing of participants—contributed to a sense of obligation and routine, further encouraging obedience.Academia
-
Sociological Perspective on Obedience: Moving beyond psychological explanations, Russell emphasizes the importance of sociological factors in understanding obedience. He argues that the organizational context and institutional support played crucial roles in shaping participants' behavior.
Russell's dissertation is recognized for its scholarly merit, offering a nuanced perspective that integrates sociological insights into the analysis of one of psychology's most famous experiments. By focusing on the structural and organizational elements, his work provides a deeper understanding of how ordinary individuals can become agents of harmful actions within certain institutional contexts.
For those interested in exploring Russell's findings in detail, both volumes of Understanding Willing Participants are available for download on Academia.edu.
No comments:
Post a Comment