Thursday, 17 April 2025

Celestial holography is a cutting-edge approach in theoretical physics that aims to unify quantum mechanics and general relativity by applying holographic principles to the celestial sphere—the "sphere at infinity" that encodes the asymptotic behavior of spacetime.

Here’s a breakdown of the key ideas:


🌌 What Is It?

Celestial holography proposes that the data of gravitational or quantum field interactions in our 4D spacetime can be fully described by a 2D conformal field theory (CFT) living on the celestial sphere at null infinity—much like how a hologram stores 3D information in 2D.

This echoes the famous AdS/CFT correspondence, but instead of using anti-de Sitter (AdS) spacetime, celestial holography applies to asymptotically flat spacetime—the kind of geometry we think best approximates our universe on large scales.


🧭 Why “Celestial”?

The term “celestial” refers to celestial coordinates (angles on the sky, like right ascension and declination) used to map null infinity, the boundary of spacetime approached by light rays and massless particles. The holographic duality maps bulk physics (like scattering amplitudes) to conformal data on this boundary sphere.


🔁 Key Concepts

  1. Scattering Amplitudes → Conformal Correlators:
    In celestial holography, ordinary particle scattering data (S-matrix elements) are recast as correlation functions of operators on the celestial sphere.

  2. Soft Theorems & Memory Effects:
    Low-energy “soft” emissions in scattering (like soft photons or gravitons) are linked to long-term memory effects (like the relative displacement of test particles) and to asymptotic symmetries—especially the Bondi-Metzner-Sachs (BMS) group, which governs symmetry at null infinity.

  3. Pasterski–Shao–Strominger (PSS) Wavefunctions:
    Pasterski helped develop a new basis of wavefunctions adapted to the conformal structure of the celestial sphere. These wavefunctions allow the S-matrix to be recast into a form suitable for holographic analysis.

  4. Black Hole Information:
    Because asymptotic symmetries are potentially infinite-dimensional, celestial holography could help preserve information that would otherwise be "lost" in black hole evaporation—addressing one version of the black hole information paradox.


🧠 Why It Matters

Celestial holography is part of a broader effort to find a holographic duality for the real universe—one that works in flat spacetime, not the exotic curved spacetimes often used in string theory. It's about asking:

Can everything happening in spacetime be encoded as a 2D theory living at its boundary?

If successful, this would:

  • Deepen our understanding of quantum gravity.

  • Offer new tools for handling scattering processes in high-energy physics.

  • Rethink spacetime itself as an emergent or secondary structure.


🎭 The Play on the Cosmic Stage

Imagine spacetime—the 4D universe we live in—as a vast theater. In this theater, particles and fields act out an intricate performance: bouncing around, colliding, creating and annihilating.

You're not sitting in the front row, though.

You're watching from the back wall of the theater, so far away that all you see is the projection of the play's shadows on the wall. That wall is the celestial sphere—the boundary of the universe, located at null infinity where light rays end up.

And here's the strange thing:

💡 The theory says: If you understand the shadows on the wall well enough, you can reconstruct the entire play.


📀 Holography: Shadows as Code

Like a hologram etched onto a 2D plate that reconstructs a 3D image when lit properly, celestial holography suggests that:

  • The physics of everything happening inside spacetime (the 4D stage)…

  • …can be encoded on the 2D celestial sphere (the wall at the edge).

But here’s the twist: instead of the image being stored like a picture, the data are stored as conformal field theory operators. These behave like actors themselves—just in a different dimension.


📡 From Scattering to Story

When two particles collide in our universe (say, in the Large Hadron Collider), they produce an outcome: new particles flying off.

Traditionally, we describe this with an S-matrix—a big table of "if you shoot this in, here's what comes out."

In celestial holography, this scattering event is reinterpreted as a story told on the celestial sphere:

  • Each particle trajectory maps to a point on the celestial sky.

  • The amplitude becomes a correlation between those points—like how the positions of stars in a constellation tell a story.

It’s as if you saw sparks fly from the stage, hit the wall, and leave faint traces—those traces, if interpreted correctly, tell you everything that happened.


🌀 Memory Effects: Lasting Traces

Now imagine the actors on stage shift their positions very slightly, imperceptibly, after a loud boom—almost like a slow dance you only notice long after. That’s the gravitational memory effect.

Celestial holography connects those long-term "shifts" to deep symmetries at the edge of the theater. It suggests these changes aren’t just random—they’re echoes of the laws of physics themselves, encoded at infinity.


🌟 Why It Feels Like Magic (but Isn’t)

Celestial holography gives us a language to:

  • Describe how gravity talks to quantum mechanics.

  • Understand spacetime as possibly emergent—just a kind of shadow cast by something deeper and more symmetrical.

It’s a bit like realizing that you’ve been reading a play, but someone tells you it’s also a code, and that code might let you rewrite reality from the edge.



So according to physics the universe is stuff and nonsense?
ChatGPT said:

That’s a fine way to put it—stuff and nonsense, and that might be the most honest summary we have.


🍂 The Stuff:

Physics gives us the stuff: particles, fields, spacetime, dark matter, spin, charge, entropy, symmetries. This is the scaffolding—the machinery that makes apples fall and stars burn. It’s precise, measurable, testable. It’s what lets GPS satellites work and predicts the Higgs boson with uncanny accuracy.

But then—

🌫️ The Nonsense:

  • Quantum indeterminacy: Particles aren’t where they should be until you look.

  • Wavefunction collapse: Reality “decides” something only when you interact with it.

  • Spacetime as emergent: What we think of as solid, continuous time and space might be a side effect of deeper, stranger rules at the edge.

  • Observer-dependence: Reality might depend on who’s looking.

  • Information paradoxes: Black holes might destroy or encode information depending on which side of theoretical grace you wake up on.

It all starts to feel like the universe is, as you say, stuff and nonsense—a poetry of measurements pasted over a myth of certainty.


Pasterski and others working in celestial holography are essentially saying:

What we think of as "real" might be a projection from the boundary, written not in objects but in relationships, correlations, and symmetries.

Which leads us back to the poet’s question:

Is the world made of things? Or is it made of ways things relate?

Physics leans increasingly toward the latter.


So yes—physics offers us equations carved in granite, but the meaning behind them?
Still a whisper.
Still nonsense, wondrously, beautifully, mathematically coherent nonsense.


No comments:

The fact that both John Rawls and Jürgen Habermas had speech impediments—Rawls with a stutter and Habermas with a cleft palate affecting h...