Dr. Lisa Feldman Barrett, a leading psychologist and neuroscientist, does not see depression primarily as a fixed, universal disease entity with a single biological cause. Instead, she interprets depression through the lens of her broader theory of emotions and brain function, which emphasizes construction, prediction, and energy regulation.
Here are the core ideas:
-
Emotions Are Constructed, Not Hardwired
In Barrett’s theory (The Theory of Constructed Emotion), emotions like sadness, anger, or fear are not innate, hardwired responses. Instead, the brain constructs them on the fly, using past experiences to predict and categorize bodily sensations in context.
→ Depression, from this view, is also constructed, not simply "triggered" or "caused" in a straightforward mechanical sense. -
Depression as a Problem of Energy Regulation
Barrett often explains that the brain’s primary task is allostasis—predicting and regulating the body’s energy needs before they arise.
→ Depression, in this framing, can be seen as a failure or breakdown in efficient allostatic regulation: the brain struggles to predict and meet the body's needs for energy, leading to persistent states of fatigue, lack of motivation, and negative mood. Depression is not just "sadness" but a deep metabolic and predictive disruption. -
Cultural and Conceptual Framing Matters
Because the brain uses concepts to construct experiences, the way a person (and their society) conceptualizes feeling states shapes how depression is experienced.
→ If someone learns to frame bodily fatigue, isolation, and withdrawal through the cultural concept of "depression," their brain will use that concept to make sense of the sensations and feelings.
→ In other cultures (or even in other personal histories), similar bodily states might be understood differently (e.g., as spiritual crisis, physical illness, social disharmony), leading to different lived experiences. -
Plasticity and Change
Barrett argues that the brain is highly plastic, meaning that experiences, practices, and interventions (therapy, social change, medication, different narratives) can actually re-train the brain's predictive models over time.
→ Depression is not a life sentence; it reflects the brain’s current way of modeling internal and external reality, and these models can change with the right supports and interventions. -
No "One Cause" or "One Cure"
Because depression is constructed out of many interwoven factors—bodily regulation, social experiences, conceptual framing, cultural narratives—there isn’t one root cause, and therefore, no single magic bullet treatment.
→ Barrett is critical of overly biological reductionist models that treat depression as simply a chemical imbalance, while also rejecting purely cognitive or purely environmental explanations.
In short:
Feldman Barrett sees depression as a complex, dynamic phenomenon involving disruptions in bodily energy regulation, shaped by past experiences, conceptual categories, and cultural frameworks. It’s constructed by the brain in context, not hardwired into us as a fixed disease. Changing how the brain predicts and regulates bodily states—and how people conceptualize and understand their experiences—can shift depressive states over time.
No comments:
Post a Comment