“Downers” in that context refers to non-ambulatory animals, usually cattle, who are too sick, weak, or injured to stand or walk. In industrial animal agriculture, these animals are often excluded from the food chain (at least officially, due to concerns about diseases like BSE—mad cow disease), or they are subjected to particularly cruel treatment, often being dragged or forklifted to slaughter.

Sunaura Taylor does address this directly in Beasts of Burden: Animal and Disability Liberation. She draws explicit parallels between the treatment of disabled animals—especially downers—and the cultural attitudes toward disabled humans.

Here’s the heart of her argument:

---

🐄 “Downers” as an intersectional figure

Taylor uses downer animals to expose a shared logic of disposability between disabled humans and disabled or “unproductive” animals. She argues that industrial agriculture and ableist culture both define beings by their utility, mobility, and economic value. Those who can’t move or can’t produce become waste—objects to be discarded or terminated.

“The downer animal is discarded because it has lost the capacity that society deems valuable—mobility, productivity, health. These are the very same metrics used to measure the worth of disabled humans.”

---

🧑‍🦽 Cross-species disability politics

Taylor powerfully suggests that ableism and speciesism share common roots. The figure of the downer animal becomes a symbol of cross-species oppression, where both human and nonhuman animals are denied care, autonomy, and dignity due to their perceived lack of utility.

She also critiques how rationales for euthanizing downers echo arguments used in eugenics and institutionalization: "they’re suffering," "they can’t contribute," "it’s more humane to end their life."

---

🧠 Philosophical intervention

Taylor’s thinking complicates the usual human-animal divide. She questions not just how we treat animals, but how we define life, value, and agency in a culture that treats stillness, fragility, and dependency as problems to be eliminated.

---

If you’d like, I can find a direct quote or help weave this into a more philosophical reflection. There’s something haunting and deeply ethical about the figure of the downer, especially in Taylor’s hands—it becomes a sort of ontological indictment of modernity.