We do not take the rough with the smooth in Apple stores, we do not confront horror, no one wants to buy pain. They do not want to tarnish the buying mood, smooth, one click, next day delivery sells. If life is suffering then life itself has been repressed, swept or one-clicked away.
This is a rather profound observation. You are describing something more consequential than clever marketing: the commercial sanitisation of human existence.
The Apple Store is an interesting metaphor because it sells more than technology. It sells an experience of frictionless possibility. Everything is illuminated, beautifully arranged, accessible and reassuring. There is no visible exhaustion, desperation, grief, failure or human vulnerability.
The rough has been excluded from the smooth.
1. The commodification of happiness
Consumer capitalism does not merely sell products that satisfy needs. Increasingly, it sells the promise that dissatisfaction itself can be eliminated through consumption.
Something is missing? Buy it.
Something is inconvenient? Automate it.
Something is difficult? Simplify it.
Something causes discomfort? Remove the friction.
The implicit promise is that the good life is a sequence of successfully resolved inconveniences.
But suffering is not an inconvenience. It is part of the human condition.
2. The disappearance of suffering
Here I think your observation touches something important in philosophy.
Consider four thinkers:
Schopenhauer: Life is characterised by suffering, desire and the perpetual dissatisfaction of willing.
Buddha: Suffering is fundamental to human existence, and understanding its causes is essential to liberation.
Adorno: The administered world attempts to reconcile individuals to existing conditions while concealing the contradictions that produce suffering.
Byung-Chul Han: Contemporary achievement-oriented society transforms individuals into entrepreneurs of themselves, encouraging relentless optimisation and self-exploitation.
The connection is particularly interesting with Adorno.
If society makes suffering invisible rather than addressing its causes, it risks confusing the disappearance of unpleasant experiences with the achievement of human emancipation.
3. The one-click society
Your phrase one-clicked away is especially effective.
One-click purchasing is not simply a technological convenience. It is emblematic of a broader cultural aspiration: the elimination of the interval between desire and satisfaction.
But that interval is where reflection, hesitation, deliberation and sometimes wisdom occur.
We might say:
Shopping without waiting.
Communication without silence.
Entertainment without boredom.
Information without contemplation.
Satisfaction without fulfilment.
The danger is that we begin to regard every form of resistance, difficulty and discomfort as a defect to be engineered away.
Yet some of the most important human experiences cannot be delivered overnight.
Friendship, love, intellectual maturity, political solidarity, forgiveness and wisdom all require time, vulnerability and the possibility of disappointment.
4. The political implications
There is also a Marxist dimension to your observation.
Capitalism can commodify the promise of happiness while leaving intact the social relations that generate insecurity, alienation and inequality.
The consumer is offered individual solutions to problems that may have collective causes.
The worker experiences exhaustion but is offered wellness products.
The lonely individual is offered digital connectivity.
The economically insecure individual is offered aspirational consumption.
The politically powerless individual is offered the illusion of choice between competing products.
The structural problem remains, while its symptoms become markets.
This is not to suggest that convenience or technology is inherently oppressive. The question is what kind of human freedom they serve.
5. A philosophical proposition
I would develop your observation into something like this:
The contemporary consumer society has become increasingly adept at eliminating the visible traces of suffering without necessarily diminishing its causes. Its ideal environment is frictionless, its transactions instantaneous and its promises reassuring. It offers a world in which desire can be satisfied with a click, inconvenience removed by automation and dissatisfaction answered by consumption.
But a society that cannot accommodate suffering may also become incapable of understanding it. By sweeping pain from the field of commercial visibility, it risks sweeping from consciousness the social conditions that produce it.
The tragedy of the one-click society is not that everything becomes easier. It is that we may gradually lose the capacity to distinguish between the elimination of unnecessary hardship and the elimination of those difficult experiences through which human beings acquire depth, solidarity and understanding.
And I would add one final thought.
Perhaps the real test of an emancipated society is not whether it can eliminate suffering through consumption, but whether it can organise itself to prevent avoidable suffering without denying the irreducible difficulties of being human.
That takes us back to Rawls, Marx and Adorno, but also to your earlier distinction between HI (Human Intelligence) and WI (Wisdom).
A society may become extraordinarily intelligent at satisfying consumers while remaining profoundly unwise about the conditions of human existence.
That, perhaps, is NS (Natural Stupidity) at its most sophisticated.
Refined version:
We do not take the rough with the smooth in Apple Stores. We do not confront horror; nobody wants to buy pain. Nothing must be allowed to tarnish the purchasing mood. Smooth surfaces, frictionless transactions, one-click purchasing and next-day delivery are what sell. But if suffering is the pith of life, as Schopenhauer and the (non-modern and un-sanitized) Buddha remind us, and if evil is the worlds antagonist and prince, what happens when they are systematically banished from the consumer's field of vision? Life itself is repressed, swept aside, sanitised, one-clicked away. And isn't this the ultimate victory of evil and suffering? Evil wins when its disappearance becomes indistinguishable from happiness, hedonia, numb comfort or routine.
Yes — but there is a deliciously disturbing paradox in your argument: by banishing suffering from the consumer's field of vision, consumer society may not overcome evil and suffering; it may secure their victory.
The distinction is between suffering as an experience and suffering as something acknowledged. Schopenhauer and the Buddha, despite their profound differences, both challenge the comforting assumption that happiness can be secured by satisfying our desires. For Schopenhauer, desire perpetually renews itself: satisfaction is temporary, boredom follows, and the wheel turns again. For the Buddha, craving and attachment are central to dukkha — suffering, dissatisfaction, the instability of existence. Neither offers much support for the idea that a sufficiently frictionless shopping experience will deliver us from the human condition.
But your argument takes a further, more radical step. It suggests that consumer society does not merely conceal suffering; it reorganises our relationship to it. Suffering becomes an interruption, an inconvenience, a defect in the customer experience. The appropriate response is no longer to understand it, confront it, or collectively transform its causes, but to remove it from view.
And here the Adornian critique becomes particularly powerful. The glossy surface of the Apple Store is not simply an aesthetic preference. It is an image of a world in which contradiction has apparently disappeared. The suffering involved in producing commodities, the inequalities that determine who can afford them, the ecological costs of their manufacture, and the anxieties that make us desire them are all kept outside the frame. The product appears immaculate because the world that made it is absent.
Yet I would qualify your final question. Is this the ultimate victory of evil and suffering? Perhaps not quite. There is a distinction worth preserving:
Suffering is concealed, but it has not disappeared.
Evil is rendered invisible, but its consequences continue.
Pain is excluded from the spectacle, but may be intensified in the reality behind it.
Indeed, the most sinister possibility is that suffering becomes more effective precisely when it becomes less visible. What cannot be acknowledged cannot easily be challenged. What is experienced as an individual inconvenience cannot readily be recognised as a collective injustice.
So perhaps the ultimate victory is not that evil and suffering have been banished, but that we have been persuaded to mistake their disappearance from the shop window for their disappearance from the world.
I would sharpen your final thought into this:
If suffering is the pith of life, then a society that systematically banishes it from the consumer's field of vision does not abolish suffering; it abolishes the conditions under which suffering can be recognised. Evil wins not when it disappears, but when its disappearance becomes indistinguishable from happiness. Life itself is repressed, swept aside, sanitised — one-clicked away.
That last distinction matters. We should not romanticise suffering, as though pain were intrinsically ennobling or injustice somehow necessary. The point is not to preserve suffering, but to refuse its sanitisation. A humane society should reduce avoidable suffering while retaining the capacity to see, name and confront it.
And perhaps there is your deepest paradox: the society that promises to remove every trace of suffering may become the society least capable of relieving it.
No comments:
Post a Comment