Chapter 1: The metaphysics of bubbles
Today we talk about spirits. I wonder if anyone can hear me. Send me a sign if you can hear me. Anybody out there?
Bubbles. Let’s talk about bubbles. We want to know about bubbles intimately if we want to understand reality at all.
And speaking of spirits, what fills the bubble? If we’re in a bubble—I think everyone agrees we are—what’s filling up the inside? What’s the gas on the inside? And there are a few other questions I have listed here. First: should we accept that bubbles are bad? We know that the meaning of “bubble” is bad. When people use the analogy, they’re not talking about something good. It’s not “Oh, yay, look at us—we’re in a bubble now.” Bubbles only have a negative meaning. But meaning is not neutral. Meaning is almost impossible to change. We can recognize that it’s arbitrary and that it evolves over time. But are bubbles bad? Is the bubble bad for you?
A bubble being bad depends on how much you have invested in it. In a certain sense, the metaphysics of the bubble is based on debt—not just economic bubbles. Bubbles have a local temporality, an inflated local temporary temporality, and their temporality is always loaned by virtue of the fact that the meaning of the bubble is that it’s going to pop. In that sense, anything temporal is loaned. It’s living on borrowed time. The analogy of bubbles gives them their meaning as this negative thing, as if we had something invested in them. So the badness of bubbles, the bad meaning of bubbles, depends on how much you have invested in it when it collapses. If you pull out, you’ll be happier. If you pull out, then you’re not going to have more than you bargained for.
Chapter 2: Capitalism as reality
If you pop over to Instagram and see the Marxist teenagers over there, if you click on one Marxist teenager meme, then that’s the feed from then on. But all they want to do is pop the bubble. They’re like accelerationists with it. If you’re trying to get elected to fix something, then you’re a reformist. And this is a negative thing, because you’re trying to fix capitalism instead of trying to overthrow it.
Interestingly, this is quite literally the core, the central organizing tenet of Buddhism as well: don’t waste your breath on the bubbles, because it’s bubbles all the way down. And you’re going to be more upset, you’re going to be less at peace after you lose your energy blowing into all these bubbles when they’re all temporary, all destined to pop. Śūnyatā.
We’d be mistaken, I think—this is implied in the Marxist Instagram teenagers’ worldview—to understand capitalism the way that Marx wrote we should understand it. Because back in the day, 150 years ago, give or take, there were alternative possibilities. You could put the possible economic systems next to each other, and a hypothetical agent could sit there and decide: all right, we’ll take some of this system and some of that system. Even by the 1850s or ’60s—I’m not an expert on this—I doubt it was even possible, but it seemed possible. Capitalism as we’ve seen it today is not merely one economic system among others. It’s reality. It’s the reality system. Meanings, signs, economies—anything you can count as real depends on capitalism, which is not just one economic system among others. It’s a meaning system.
Chapter 3: Overthrowing the system
And a meaning system is not the kind of thing that can just be overthrown. An analogy would be language. You can imagine overthrowing a language. You can see languages appear, disappear, and die. But language is not the kind of thing that can be overthrown, no matter how much effort you put into it—even though we know it will end. There will be a day when the last word is uttered. There will be a day when the last written sign is written down and there will be none after that. But there’s not much we can do from this side to hasten the collapse.
That’s not to say I don’t applaud the memes. I think if you’re going to get up to do anything, overthrowing reality is a good goal. It’s a lofty goal. So yeah, I applaud the memes. I do. But it’s not the kind of thing anymore—if it ever was—that you can get outside of the bubble in order to look as if from the outside. It’s more like you look into the edge of the bubble and you’re seeing a reflection, but it appears that you’re looking forward into space when you’re not. It’s an illusion.
Capitalism is no longer, if it ever was, the kind of thing where you have some sort of lever to put all the options on the table and sit outside of the decision enough to make an informed choice. That’s not a real possibility. And that’s what overthrowing capitalism means—unless you mean just hastening the end of the world. At least not with Marxism. That’s my contention. Marxism is a mirror of capitalism. And if you want to have an alternative to capitalism, the place to start looking is in systems that preceded it, that had very little to do with it, that weren’t contaminated by the virality of capitalism. Ancient metaphysics, Greek metaphysics, Buddhist, even primitive mythologies—these sustained themselves for a long time without that influence. It might be a place to look. I’m not saying it’s a slam dunk.
Chapter 4: The reality of bubbles
The question is: if we’re looking to pop a bubble here, if the teenagers on Instagram are looking to pop a bubble, is capitalism the one we should be doing? Because it does satisfy the criteria of a bubble. It’s got a spirit. It’s built on debt, obviously. It’s got a local temporality that doesn’t sync up with the time outside of it. That’s what I’m talking about today: the temporality. Where does the temporality of capitalism come from? And it’s got the energy and faith of enough people to sustain it. But it might not be the bubble.
David Graeber might be someone who fits this bill. He suggests no, it’s human civilization—human sedentary civilization after we invented agriculture. That’s the actual bubble here. That’s like a 10,000-year-old bubble. No matter what bubble you want to point at, though, some of them aren’t the kind of things that we can pop. Even if we read the Communist Manifesto, you still can’t imagine the surface without some of the particular bubbles—which is not to say it’s not possible.
There was a time when it would have been absolutely inconceivable to overthrow God, for example. Now we’ve reduced God to merely a sign. Back in the day the Gnostics tried it. They were killed, and God made it up until at least the 19th century. So it’s not a suggestion that we accept reality. This whole thing is about reality. Psychotics are out there on the daily doing their damnedest to overthrow reality. And reality is arbitrary. It’s inherited. It’s a sort of organic evolution. But it turns out that no matter how arbitrary it is, overthrowing reality is inconceivable—like overthrowing language.
Even though realities, including capitalism, will all have their last breath—there will be a last moment of capitalism, there will be a last moment of language—it doesn’t really seem like the kind of thing we can do much about to end it. And even if we could, I want you to think about this.
Chapter 5: The aftermath of collapse
No one asked this. I don’t know anyone asking this question. Let’s think about if you had the button to push to end capitalism. Would you do that? Don’t say yes too fast. If you can, should we overthrow capitalism? What would the world look like the day after capitalism? Because I don’t think it would be a classless utopia. It might look something more like balkanized military contractor states. It would look like Russia in the ’90s, except even worse. We’re talking mass death, mass starvation, and a few more pull themselves out of the ruins of capitalism. Most of us wouldn’t have a chance. I wouldn’t have a chance there.
You don’t get classless society when the bubble pops. That’s insane. What you get when the bubble pops is balkanized military states. Presumably some of the electricity infrastructure is still there, but it’s not going to come to your house. And that’s if the Earth doesn’t turn into Venus as the end of capitalism, which is a pretty likely outcome. God created the Earth with Venus next to it so that we would realize: you have any turn-off point that you want. This is your destiny. But if you elect AOC as president, you won’t have to live through this destiny.
Post-capitalism doesn’t look like Eden, though. And I don’t know how seriously to take teenagers on Instagram, because they’re really good at memes, and it’s kind of hard to tell whether they believe anything or not.
There are benefits to the capitalist meaning system—namely that you can make whatever you want out of anything you want. Now, the main problem with the meaninglessness of the capitalist system is like the meaninglessness of Warhol art. I made a video about the meaninglessness of Warhol art, and the thing was extolling Warhol for his virtue. If anyone made it to the end, it looks like I’m just on it as bad art. And it is bad art, but it’s also capitalist art, because you have the infinite reversibility of any possible oppositions. There’s no master signs, because all the solids have melted into air and all the sacreds have been profaned. And that’s thanks to capitalism.
Chapter 6: Protestantism and capitalism
The capitalist algorithm killed God and tribe and the genders and any signs that you could hold up to discipline the others. The death of God is more utile than God himself actually was. And now God is unconscious, which is maybe the most useful he could be. But we’re not using any of the potential here. We’re not using any of the virtual energy that we’ve been bestowed with.
And I find that particularly why the thesis associated with Max Weber—that capitalism is kind of a secularized theology—is compelling. It’s a Protestant theology. The spirit of capitalism is Protestant, which is compelling for a number of reasons. They appear at the same time. The roots of it, anyway: 16th century, Western Europe. Which caused which? For Weber, it’s clear which caused which. The Protestants were anxious. The Protestants could not achieve ataraxia. So the anxious Protestants, the Calvinists, sought to throw their energy into the world because of anxiety. And then God died, and those anxious world-changers became secular producers.
So the need to produce comes from a religious anxiety. And I don’t even mean historically what happened. I mean metaphysically what happens. Protestantism and capitalism—they’re twins. They’re suckling the same teat. Because as soon as you invent this sort of history as a resource, history as an objective resource that needs to be handled, that needs to be manhandled by labor, you invent linear time and history. And the second that you invent linear time plus history, you’ve also invented the end of history, haven’t you? The end of history as a whimper or a pop. The pop is the ultimate realization. It’s the only event that has meaning. And when the pop happens, then everything that is a hallucination reveals itself as hallucination.
Chapter 7: Linear time and anxiety
In linear history, in Protestantism, the world is kind of fake. But you have nothing else but the fake. Calvinism: you don’t have anything but the fake. So you might as well put all your effort into the fake in the chance that it amounts to some value in the end. That sounds kind of like inflation. That sounds kind of like a bubble: if you invest value in a fake enough that the fake becomes real.
Anything that happens on earth prior to the pop, prior to the end of history—I can’t really recall my Calvinism; I don’t think they’re necessarily millenarians. I think the Calvinist thought is: we are completely depraved. All of us deserve hell and we’re all going to hell, except God, for arbitrary reasons, for no reason, is going to save some people. But you’re so depraved that this is going to come down to luck. And since it comes down to luck, since it comes down to gambling in the first place, you should change this fake world as much as possible, just in case it helps your case a tiny little bit. Just if it stacks the odds in your favor that much on judgment day. It shouldn’t. It probably won’t, because God is sovereign and all that. But if it’s between you and the next guy and you built railroads and used some of the proceeds to help orphans and fund libraries, then maybe you’re going to be the one who squeaks in there.
So God’s grace doesn’t come from anything you’ve done. But since it doesn’t matter anyway, since the slate is going to be wiped, since the bubble’s going to pop, you may as well increase your chances of not being damned to hell if you can. This is produced by a hyperactive cosmic anxiety over the outcome of a roulette table. That’s the basis of capitalist psychology. I hope that makes sense of how we arrived in the Calvinist universe. None of these people deserve it, but that guy built a nice tower, so I’m going to go with the tower guy. So you might as well build a tower, because you have nothing else to do here, because the entire history is meaningless.
Chapter 8: Meaninglessness of death
When you see gambling, every ad is a gambling ad. You feel the Calvinist ethic coming back—not first as tragedy, then as farce, then as fart. Now Calvinism is a fartcoin. That’s the result of linear time in a bubble, because history’s fake. Calvinism believes that history’s fake, except we have nothing else. So it’s quite a tragic existence unless you’re one of the lucky few who are chosen despite being totally depraved and despite nothing that you do on earth having any value. So Calvinism is pretty real with it.
But it also makes death now extremely tragic, because you can’t have a meaningful death. You can die saving a busload of toddlers, but it’s the same as dying in a pedophile orgy. No matter what your death is, it’s meaningless. You’re dying under a hegemony you couldn’t control. You might have believed that you had the chance to control it, like the Marxist teenagers on Instagram. And then you die in the futility of knowing that history is changeable but never having had the capacity to change anything in your life. So you live in a simulation, you’re told it’s a simulation, you invent for yourself the tools to change history, and you die unable to have done anything. You live in pain and then you die in pain for no reason. The emotional burden of that as your existence is worse than the event of death itself, because the event of death itself is nothing.
And the thing is, prior to having this linear time introduced into history, death was always reversible. Prime example: the ancestors are buried in the middle of the town, as opposed to modern graveyards being pushed into the industrial district. The difference of having them at the center of town is you can tell that that society believes in a reversibility of death. But if you die in the Calvinist/capitalist universe for no reason, struggling for stuff that you can’t take with you, death is irreversible. And that’s what you get as a result of linear time.
Chapter 9: The capitalist meaning void
So the spirit of capitalism, when capitalism had a spirit—Calvinism—is just labor and anxiety of death. It’s an anxious existence. It’s thoughtless, because what’s the point of thinking? What’s the point of any of it? It’s all linear until the end. And you don’t know if anything you did—because you’re totally depraved—has an effect on the end. And the master sign is the pop. That’s when God returns. God’s absent your entire life. He comes back for a moment to judge you, and then you find out what everything meant along the way. Then you find out finally, in the very last act, as the curtain call, whether you’ve been living in hell or whether you’ve been living in heaven.
Now capitalism is even worse, if that’s possible. It’s even worse than Calvinism, because in this logic of the bubble you are not allowed to acknowledge that there’s a pop. There’s simply magic hands that push value down and magic hands that push value up. And there is no pop. There is no end. The end of capitalism is the end of natural resources or something like that. So you take away even the salvation that gave the futility of the Calvinist world meaning. You even take that away. So now you have labor in anxiety, die, nothing. That’s a lot to look forward to.
Chapter 10: The rise of QAnon
This nihilistic bubble is why we need QAnon. I mean, it’s not nihilistic suddenly now that we get capitalism. The Calvinist view is also nihilistic, because it’s a roll of the dice. God’s dice roll whether or not it was worth anything. So this is the progression of a particular modern anxiety. Protestants remove God from life and push him to the end of life, to the pop, to the judgment. But then the capitalist system, Protestantism’s twin, comes along to say: Wait, what pop? There’s no pop. This is not a bubble. This is the world. Then God’s dead. And there’s not even a dice roll at the end to give the stuff value retroactively. There’s only the stuff. There’s the stuff in a void. You’re not even gambling on your life being worth something. It just by definition is worth nothing. It is by definition the things, the comforts you can accumulate for retirement, which you may or may not get—15 years to enjoy, or you die—and that’s the only coherence: those 15 years of reprieve.
But this is why we need QAnon. These are the options. This is the menu. This is the dollar menu in hell. So you need QAnon because QAnon redeems the world while the world still exists, before the curtain call. QAnon gives meaning to the world as it is. It appears to be a chaotic, turbulent, disturbed mess. But there’s an order to it. There’s a logos that explains why everything looks like this.
Calvinism denies us that. The rest of Christianity, the older Christianities, give you some reversibility. They give you some cyclical time. They take the old gods and put them into the new religion. Calvinism just gets rid of everything. So you have zero coherence until on your deathbed God flips a coin and decides whether your life meant anything or not. So yes, you need QAnon. They’ve created the conditions in which QAnon is a necessity. And I got to say, I can’t wait until season two. Season one, the writing at the end kind of fell off, but I’m looking forward to season two. The technology was cooked up by a spirit cooker who prays to Satan and the world’s most prolific pedophile teaming up with Bill Gates, who right now stands at the threshold of the gates of hell. Season one, yeah, it was terrifying. Season two, equally terrifying. But you know, I’m starved for some artistic creation here.
Chapter 11: Master signs in decline
Social realities accept ours. What makes ours unique is that usually a social reality depends on a master sign. A master sign stabilizes the rest of the system. They can’t be questioned. They wouldn’t have been able to call them signs, because a sign by definition is arbitrary. And if you let the arbitrariness show through, then the master sign has collapsed—like God. God was a master sign, but now it’s pretty clear that he doesn’t exist. And up until recently we still had signs that did the same work that God was doing when he fell off, like freedom. You’d have to be crazy to be opposed to freedom or to question whether freedom is good or not. Just as 200 years ago you would be crazy to question whether God exists or not believe in him. Democracy is one of our recent fall-offs. If there is anyone out there who still questions the power of our democracy… [Obama quote]… and still, for most people, you’d have to be crazy to be opposed to democracy. I don’t know if democracy is the last domino, but it’s getting near the end here. If democracy was a functional master sign, then QAnon would not need to exist. It would not exist. There’s a disciplinary sign that stabilizes the rest of the chaos of appearances. But when the arbitrariness of signs shows through, there’s no way of predicting what you’re going to get. But you get QAnon once everything has been destabilized. There’s no possibility of cosmic coherence anymore. There’s only such a thing as temporary reprieve.
Chapter 12: Temporary reprieve
And temporary reprieve takes the form of the very consumer-egotistical type of Christianity where Christianity is a kind of feel-good session where you can buy the pastor’s books and you don’t even know one other person’s name. You just go there because they give you a feel-good session. Or the TikTok whatever they’re calling new thought—when you send your energy into the universe, manifesting. All of this stuff is meant to be temporary reprieve from the fact that capitalism—not the economic system, but the reality system—killed the hierarchy of signs and every sign is now free. So the only thing to do is a type of schizoid meaning creation where you associate two things temporarily, extract meaning from it. Meaning is a temporary resource. So then you find two other things and connect them, extract the meaning from it. And this can be a cool creative process. I think QAnon was a pretty cool creative process. It’s like: look at this still image from a video I found—there looks like a black triangle in here. Black triangle is the sign of this demon. This demon is present here in the celebrity, which proves that Britney Spears died and was replaced by a hologram because the pedophile cabal killed Britney Spears as a child and then pretended to make her grow up into an adult with a shaved head. Whatever QAnon’s doing, it’s creating connections that well-adjusted people would say is horseshit. But I’m here to say that even the well-adjusted people’s connections that they make—how they also pretend they’re involved in history so that they can get through a day—it’s equally spurious.
Chapter 13: Living in interesting times
My logic here is that we actually live in the most interesting times. “May you live in interesting times”—this is the folk wisdom that says it’s a traditional Chinese curse. But no signs at least since the ’70s (which is kind of an arbitrary date, but sometime in the ’70s) all sign hierarchies collapsed. The world quietly ended and no one really noticed. I don’t know what the event was. Maybe it’s the end of the Bretton Woods system. But from then on sign hierarchies were done. You see it on all the graphs if you look: there’s something that happens in the ’70s, and no signs depend on any other. So we can’t have God. We can’t have production. We can’t have history. We don’t have a tribe anymore. There’s no genders anymore. Sexual difference is no longer necessary in the science system. So we got what we wanted. We got freedom. All the signs are free. And I don’t know that that has never happened before.
There are precedents to signs being free. Like Zen Buddhism will teach something like: the signs are already all free; it’s just that no one has realized it. But they are locked in monasteries, right? So the benefit of keeping mystics and monks and Zen Buddhists and the desert fathers and the Stoics all locked in monasteries somewhere is that they can’t corrupt the youth anymore. They can’t corrupt the general feeling. Living in interesting times is a blessing if you know what to look for, if you know how to do it. Because the challenge is then: how do you create coherence when there’s no naturally occurring coherences? And this is a premise of semiotics: that there never was a natural signification. That all of it was always arbitrary. But we’ve never realized that it was all arbitrary before. In the same way that you’re not supposed to realize when you’re in a bubble—and now we can. Now we can realize that we’re in a bubble while we’re in it. And still the system can keep on ticking as if it’s not in a bubble when everybody knows it is. This seems to be unprecedented.
So the thing that we can’t fake, the thing that everyone’s trying to bring back or push into the future, is this thing: coherence. How do you order the signs? This is something you can’t fake, you can’t buy. So capitalism has basically no interest in it. Capitalism seems to prefer the anxiety route. And that’s new too.
Chapter 14: Coherence and death
It used to be, before capitalism, that sign systems were the opposite. They were not liberated. They were all rigid so that everything had a clear and distinct meaning, including death. So death was not nearly so feared, because it had an inherent meaning depending on where it was in the sign system of the culture that’s using it. But like I said before, the dead weren’t buried in the industrial land, the industrial district where the land is cheap. The dead were buried at the center of town. This was not something that was always avoided the way that it’s avoided now. The reason that it’s avoided now is this vast unknown. It doesn’t seem to have any opposite. You could say that life is the opposite, but they’re not reversible. Death and life are not reversible. It seems to be a one-way relationship. And that’s, in the whole scope of human history, very uncommon for death to be the end without being also something else simultaneously. Death always matters, but it’s not avoided because it’s always on the way to something. So life and death are usually reversible. Usually you can have some contact with the dead. The dead are not nothing. The dead are something.
So where death is in the system—all of the wisdom on the matter, and I’m just going to do the Wisdom capital W: what most of the wisdom literature, philosophy, religions, the monastic types, versions of the religions anyway—their ongoing question is how to make death coherent within life. And they all settle… I don’t like when people say all religions are the same, but this question seems to always be answered the same up until recently, up until Calvinism. Calvinism is completely nihilistic with respect to coherence. It says: work your ass off because the dice get rolled at the end of your life, and if you can cross your fingers and get weighted dice at the end, that’s the best outcome. You’re totally depraved. You’re born into sin. Nothing you can do can change that. But if you work really, really, really hard, you might be able to weigh the dice at the end to give yourself a better chance. Good job, faithful servant.
Chapter 15: The emptiness of modernity
But capitalism says: work your ass off and there’s no dice roll. We can’t really live in that, and no one really does. There’s a performance going on where we pretend that we don’t believe what we believe—which is no surprise that the unconscious gets invented under capitalism, because we need somewhere for all of this logic, all these energies to go. Now Marxism says basically the same thing as capitalism: work your ass off and then… profit. Step three: profit. Good job, faithful servant. Try not to sell your labor because it’s really yours. That’s the best-case outcome. But you got to work on it hard.
You can go before this current bubble and see what they were doing to solve the problem that we can’t even see as a problem. And they said that what we need is already everywhere. You just have to know how to look for it. Now this is something I need to tell myself on the daily. Of course it turns out to be, I think, true: that what you need is already everywhere. The thing is, in the logic of capitalism, something that’s everywhere has no value. There would be no demand for it.
Now the wisdom literature knows about the question of meaning in a way that every conceivable modern viewpoint—everything I read on Twitter—just believes is not a problem. Like conservatives correctly believe: well, meaning is in the past. Now meaning is in the past. But we can’t get their meaning back, because we do not have a hierarchy of signs anymore, because capitalism. Capitalism says there’s no such thing as meaning because it doesn’t have any use for it—because if it’s everywhere it doesn’t need it. So it just pretends like it doesn’t exist. And Marxism says: well, meaning and economics are the same thing. Or it says: let’s get this revolution done with and then everyone can find their own meaning. So there’s a special hollowness to modernity where we know we all want meaning, but we all believe that it doesn’t exist. We all believe that it’s nothing. We do believe that there’s meaning in the past (conservatism) or in the future (revolution), but we all agree that there is no meaning in the here and now. Our religions agree on that. Capitalism agrees on that. Our anti-capitalism agrees on that. There is no meaning to be found in the here and now. So meaning has no meaning. And you know, even I accept that. I can accept that meaning is nothing. But nothing is all over the place. And this is what all the wisdom agrees upon.
Chapter 16: Wisdom and ataraxia
Ataraxia itself—being at peace—does not give meaning to death in a signifying sense. But it does subtract the fear of death, which is kind of the only meaning that we have for it right now. We only have anxiety and avoidance and trying to prolong the arrival of death. But in the other sense, death as the end of the struggle is basically subtracting its meaning. So the purpose of life in all the meditative traditions and in wisdom and all this is to subtract the fear of death so you don’t live in fear, because that is a shitty life to live. And it all basically agrees on that. You go across continents, you go across centuries, and they all agree on that: let’s make death a non-event.
Chapter 17: Practicing meaning
So the goal then of the meditation and the prayer and the thinking and the poetry writing and the philosophizing—all that the wisdom did—is to make the before-death, the moment before death, identical to the one after. That you prepare to die. You spend your whole life thinking, poetizing, doing art, praying, meditating, fasting, so that when you die there’s no pop that happens at all, because the moment prior to death is equivalent to the one after. We probably recognize some Stoicism in this: to be non-reactive, because what is death but non-reactive? You don’t react ever again. So the ataraxia, the seeking of undisturbedness—death is the primary fear. And if you can negate the primary fear, then what else is there to fear? What is there to be anxious about? Because you’re going to die anyway. And if your death is meaningless in the sense that it’s nothing to fear, that’s why this becomes a pursuit across centuries, across continents. This is again why they lock them in monasteries—the people who talk like this.
But the wisdom teachers and the sages are trying to eliminate the meaning of death because they look around and everyone’s hyperactive, hyper-anxious, emotional, overreactive because of precisely this fear—this fear that leaks out into everything else. But if all you have is the fear of death, that’s obviously the recipe for egotistic anxiety. Or: the universe is watching me and all I have to do is make sigils and send them out into the universe and the universe will reward me. It’s the same thing. Everything seems to not make sense. Everything seems insane, but secretly Trump is doing magic cult war and that’s why everything looks chaotic, but it’s not.
And how do we do it? What is the QAnon meditative practice? Pouring over the Q, the clues. They’re like Sherlock Holmes and Watson and Encyclopedia Brown and Nancy Drew pouring over the clues so that they can offer their life force to Trump as a sacrifice. And he will say: well done, my good and faithful servant. You solved the riddle. But the incoherence necessarily produces angst, anxiety, terror—all that bad stuff. Coherentlessness is the sign that there is no inherent meaning hierarchy anymore that we have immediate access to.
Now the closest thing in the West is like Christian conservatism, and the only thing they can say is: yeah, we lost all this, so let’s go back and it will be the same—when that’s not true. Now they’re right that somewhere some sign hierarchy did exist that was uncorrupted. But now it’s corrupted. That’s the problem. You can’t just assemble new tokens together when the tokens—now you know in your heart, in your unconscious—that these have equivalent value. You can’t decide. You can’t say: okay everybody, this token now has the most value; we’re going to try to build a system on top of it. Because you know you don’t believe that anymore. That’s what modern religion is like, unless you grew up under a rock or you grew up in a cult. But the second that you have some sense that there’s someone out there who believes in their god exactly the same way that you believe in your god, you can never get that certainty back. You can never get the coherence of the structure back. And even if you can as an individual, you can’t build a society on it.
So that’s why you get meaning. Meaning is everything. Everything can be meaningful, which does feel good for a while—the new thought, praying to the universe with sigils, or Q-ing—all of it feels good for a while. It’s like coke. Everything’s connected until the crash, until the hangover, and then nothing’s worth it. So as opposed to getting addicted to stimulants, the goal of ataraxia is long-term control: no ups, no downs, or control at least over the ups and downs when they inevitably occur. And if this is the case, then you’re ready for death before death. And death can’t bother you. The yawning chasm of the void won’t bother you because you’ve managed to get yourself into your own void. And this is what all the focus and the prayer and the meditation and the fasting is all about: it’s to break down the systems that are causing you fear already. What if I don’t have enough food? Well, what if I voluntarily abstain from food? What am I going to do next? What am I going to do so that… what am I going to do tonight? You’re resisting the urge to give in to the anxiety. And they figured it out. They figured it out in ancient India and they figured it out in ancient Greece and everywhere.
So the enemies then become unbalanced and unhingedness and emotionally overreactive states. Those are all the states of anxiety over death or the state of a lack of control. But I think I’ve got the case to be made here that the capitalist meaning system, in destroying all the other meaning systems, actually has made the wisdom easier. Because in any previous wisdom you have to overcome all the inherited wisdom to get to the true wisdom. Now there’s nothing to overcome, because nothing means anything and anything means nothing. All the solids have melted into air. All the sacreds are profaned. You already know that you can’t get meaning from the God in the church, because God is everywhere. The downside of God being everywhere is that he can’t do anything anymore. So that’s a bummer. He can’t send you to heaven when you die. That’s a bummer. But he’s in everything. That includes every shitty thing. He’s in every Warhol soup can.
If you can create the connections, if you can see what is there virtually if not actually, and this can be practiced. This is something I take seriously: that the meaning of meaning can be practiced. And I think it has to be, because if you do that honestly you’re not in hell, because hell would be meaningless. You’re only in hell if you don’t try. So sure, you can admit for the first time that everything means nothing. But it’s because everything means nothing that we can see for the first time what nothing actually means. And that, I’m sorry, I’m going to have to save for another day.
You know, the post-philosophy gave up on this path. It seems like there was Schopenhauer and then the junior Schopenhauerians and they kind of led to a dead end, because people were like: nihilism. We’re not going to do that. Of course we’re not going to do that. We don’t want nihilism. We want history. But if history ends, what have you got left but nothing? Everyone stop talking about nothing. It might be worth talking about. There’s more nothing out there than there is something out there. So it’s worth considering at the very least.
All right, take care you guys. Practice in the Aristotelian sense".
No comments:
Post a Comment