The usual way to compare costs of energy sources is by Levelized Cost of Electricity (LCOE), which averages total costs over the lifetime of a project (construction, fuel, maintenance, financing, etc.) into a per-megawatt-hour (MWh) figure.
The latest big global comparisons (IEA, Lazard, U.S. EIA, IRENA, 2023–2024 data) generally rank sources like this (approximate global averages; actual costs vary by country and financing):
Cheapest → Most expensive (LCOE, $/MWh, 2023–24 ranges)
-
Utility-scale Solar PV — $25–50
-
Prices keep falling; lowest in sunny regions with cheap financing.
-
-
Onshore Wind — $30–60
-
One of the most cost-competitive sources; stable or falling.
-
-
Hydropower (large-scale) — $35–80
-
Very cheap once built, but highly site-dependent; huge upfront cost.
-
-
Nuclear (existing plants, lifetime extensions) — $40–70
-
Extending old plants is cheap; new builds are very expensive.
-
-
Geothermal — $45–90
-
Stable and dispatchable; depends on suitable geology.
-
-
Offshore Wind — $70–120
-
Costs are coming down, but still higher due to construction complexity.
-
-
New Nuclear (new builds) — $120–200+
-
High capital costs, delays, and financing risks make new projects expensive.
-
-
Fossil fuels
-
Natural Gas (combined cycle) — $45–100 (cheap where gas is abundant, but volatile with fuel prices).
-
Coal — $65–150 (often uncompetitive now, especially with carbon pricing).
-
Oil-fired generation — $150–250+ (used mainly for backup in islands/remote regions).
-
Big picture
-
Cheapest globally today: Solar PV and onshore wind.
-
Most expensive: New nuclear, oil, and some coal.
-
Most stable (not fuel-price sensitive): Renewables and nuclear.
-
Most volatile: Gas and coal, since they depend on global commodity markets.
Do you want me to make a ranked chart just for Canada or the UK (since policies, subsidies, and geography shift costs a lot), or keep it global?
ChatGPT said:
Here’s a ranked cost comparison of energy sources in the UK, using the latest reliable government data (expressed in £ per MWh, real 2021/2022 prices) — ranked from least to most expensive:
UK Energy Sources: Ranked by Levelized Cost of Electricity (LCOE)
Rank | Energy Source | Estimated LCOE (£/MWh) | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
1⃣ | Onshore Wind | ~£38 | Most cost-effective; strong economies of scale. electricity info+1Wikipedia |
2⃣ | Large-Scale Solar PV | ~£41 | Slightly higher than onshore wind but still very competitive. electricity info+1 |
3⃣ | Offshore Wind | ~£44 | More expensive than onshore but still much cheaper than fossil fuels. electricity info+1Wikipedia |
4⃣ | Combined Cycle Gas Turbine (CCGT) | ~£114 | When forecast for 2025; still meaningfully more costly than renewables even without carbon capture. electricity info |
5⃣ | New Nuclear (e.g., Hinkley/Sizewell C) | ~£109–£132* | Estimated cost around £109 (DESNZ new nuclear central estimate) to ~£132 strike price; Hinkley LCOE ranges dependent on financing assumptions. electricity infoWorld Nuclear NewsFinancial Times |
*DESNZ figure (~£109) refers to new nuclear central estimate; Hinkley-based LCOE including financing at ~£132/MWh. electricity infoWorld Nuclear News
Summary Ranking (Cheapest → Most Expensive)
-
Onshore Wind (~£38/MWh)
-
Large-Scale Solar PV (~£41/MWh)
-
Offshore Wind (~£44/MWh)
-
CCGT (Gas) (~£114/MWh)
-
New Nuclear (~£109–£132/MWh)
Additional Context & Insights
-
Solar PV is becoming increasingly competitive: One projection suggests that large-scale solar could drop dramatically to ~£17/MWh by 2035 under optimistic scenarios, potentially undercutting all other sources. PubMed Central
-
Renewables vs Gas: The Imperial College Grantham Institute notes that as of 2023, the LCOE for solar and wind (around £41–48/MWh) is substantially lower than gas (~£124/MWh including carbon price), reinforcing that renewables are already cost-efficient. Imperial College London
-
Local example of high cost: The older Greater Gabbard offshore wind project (built around 2011) had an LCOE of £137/MWh, highlighting how older projects and infrastructure differences can impact costs. Wikipedia
Final Thoughts
-
Renewables — especially onshore wind and solar — are currently the cheapest electricity sources in the UK.
-
Offshore wind remains competitive, though more expensive due to infrastructure and installation complexity.
-
Natural gas is significantly more expensive when considering carbon pricing.
-
New nuclear falls between renewables and gas, and while higher in cost, is valued for its stable, low-carbon baseload generation.
Would you like me to break this down further—for instance:
-
By expected future costs (e.g., projected 2025–2035 changes)?
-
Cost comparisons including system-level factors (energy storage, grid integration)?
-
A cost comparison for small modular reactors (SMRs)?
Let me know—happy to dig deeper!
No comments:
Post a Comment