A lot of people with panic disorder do feel like they're in a low-level (or "background") state of anxiety or tension most of the time.
Here's the breakdown based on how panic disorder actually works (pulling from reliable sources like the DSM-5 criteria, NIMH, Mayo Clinic, and clinical descriptions):
- The core of panic disorder is recurrent, unexpected panic attacks — those sudden, intense waves of terror that hit hard and peak fast (usually within minutes). They often come with physical stuff like racing heart, shortness of breath, dizziness, feeling like you're losing control or dying, etc.
- That anticipatory anxiety — the constant low-key dread of "what if another one hits right now?" — can absolutely feel like a steady, simmering state of unease or low-level panic running in the background. It's not the full-blown attack, but it's exhausting and can make you feel "on edge" all the time, hyper-aware of your body, or like calm never fully returns.
However, panic disorder isn't defined by being in constant low-level panic 24/7 as the main feature. That's more typical of something like generalized anxiety disorder (GAD), where the primary thing is excessive, hard-to-control worry about everyday stuff (health, money, relationships, etc.) that stays at a chronic, lower-but-persistent level without necessarily spiking into full panic attacks.
People can (and often do) have both at the same time, or the constant vigilance from panic disorder can start to feel GAD-like over time.
A clinician would approach this systematically and neutrally, trying to understand baseline anxiety, not just panic episodes. Below are the exact kinds of questions that are typically asked, grouped by what they’re trying to clarify. You don’t need to answer them here unless you want to—this is to show how the distinction is made.
1. Baseline anxiety (this is the core of GAD)
These questions come first because GAD is about what’s there when nothing is happening:
-
On an average day, when you’re not in a stressful situation, do you still feel anxious or tense?
-
Is there a background sense of unease or dread that’s present most days?
-
When you wake up, do you already feel anxious before thinking about the day?
-
Does anxiety feel like your default state rather than a reaction?
Why this matters:
GAD requires anxiety on most days for months, not just during triggers.
2. Nature of worry (cognitive vs physical)
Clinicians listen carefully to how anxiety shows up:
-
Do you experience ongoing “what if” thoughts?
-
Do worries jump from one topic to another?
-
Do you feel driven to think things through to prevent bad outcomes?
-
Or is your anxiety more a physical feeling without clear thoughts?
GAD leans cognitive, panic leans physical—but overlap is common.
3. Breadth of worry (specific vs generalized)
This is a major discriminator:
-
Do you worry about many areas of life (school/work, health, family, future, money, relationships)?
-
Or does anxiety mostly cluster around specific situations (being out, being around people, transitions)?
-
If one area is calm, does anxiety move to another?
GAD worry tends to spread, not stay contained.
4. Controllability of worry
This is actually part of the diagnostic criteria:
-
Once worry starts, can you let it go?
-
Do you feel stuck in your thoughts even when you know they’re unhelpful?
-
Do you feel compelled to mentally prepare or rehearse?
GAD worry is typically hard to control.
5. Duration and continuity
Clinicians look for persistence:
-
Has this been present for 6 months or more?
-
Were there long stretches where anxiety was absent?
-
Did anxiety continue even during relatively safe or enjoyable periods?
Panic disorder often has ups and downs; GAD is flatter and more continuous.
6. Physical symptoms outside panic
GAD includes chronic physical tension:
-
Muscle tension (jaw, neck, shoulders)
-
Fatigue
-
Restlessness
-
Difficulty concentrating
-
Irritability
-
Sleep disturbance unrelated to panic
These occurring independently of panic attacks support GAD.
7. Relationship between anxiety and panic
This is subtle but crucial:
-
Did anxiety exist before the first panic attacks?
-
Does anxiety persist even when panic attacks decrease?
-
Do you feel anxious even when you don’t fear panic at that moment?
If yes, GAD may be underlying.
8. Response to reassurance
This often differentiates patterns:
-
When someone reassures you, does it help briefly or not at all?
-
Do you seek reassurance repeatedly?
-
Does reassurance shift your worry to something else?
Reassurance often fails in GAD.
9. Function without avoidance
Clinicians assess what anxiety does when avoidance is removed:
-
If you stay in situations despite anxiety, does it gradually reduce?
-
Or does anxiety remain high and migrate elsewhere?
Persistent anxiety despite exposure suggests GAD.
How a clinician would integrate this
No single answer decides it. Instead, they look for a pattern:
-
GAD = chronic, diffuse, hard-to-control anxiety across domains
-
Panic-based anxiety = episodic, situational, fear-of-fear driven
Many people fall in between.
No comments:
Post a Comment